Daily Fare
Buttermilk Muffins
blueberry
cranberry walnut
cranberry walnut
$3.00
Molasses Coffee Cake
$3.00
Currant & Orange Zest Scones
$3.00
Daily Savory Scones
cheddar & chive
bacon & cheddar
bacon & cheddar
$3.50
Savory Puff Pastries
ham & swiss with fresh thyme
fig & goat cheese with rosemary & sea salt
caramelized pear, blue cheese, and pecan
fig & goat cheese with rosemary & sea salt
caramelized pear, blue cheese, and pecan
$4.75
Lunch Fare
Quiche
smoked ham & gorgonzola artichoke heart, roasted red pepper, with fontina cheese bacon, caramelized onion, and sage ❖ plus weekly specials ❖
by the slice
$8.00
whole (pre-order only)
$37.00
Chicken Pot Pie
made with herb crusted roasted organic chicken, caramelized pearl onions, carrots, celery, mushrooms, topped with our flakey pie crust and fresh sage
6” Individual pie
$10.75
Granola & Yogurt
to stay or to go, our homemade granola is chock-full of fruits and nuts and sweetened only with maple syrup. local and organic yogurt with homemade fruit compote or honey
$7.00
Pie
☛ Check out our Pie List for current flavors!
by the slice
$6.00
small pies
$7.50
Add
homemade whipped cream
$1.50
Add
Brooklyn Ice Cream Factory’s vanilla
$3.50
Sweet Treats
Cookies
ranger cookies - oats, raisins, chocolate chips. sweet & salty
snickerdoodles - the classic tangy butter cookie with cinnamon & sugar
chocolate crinkle cookies - chewy fudgy cookie rolled in powdered sugar
snickerdoodles - the classic tangy butter cookie with cinnamon & sugar
chocolate crinkle cookies - chewy fudgy cookie rolled in powdered sugar
$2.00
or 3 for
$5.00
Brownies
crunchy outside fudgey inside brownies - peanut butter chip - peppermint patty -maple pecan
$3.50
Baby Chocolate Bourbon Bundt Cakes
the baby version of our popular chocolate cake soaked in a bourbon buttermilk glaze
$4.25
Apple Tea Bread
a loaf cake brimming with apple slices
$3.75
Carrot Cake Tea Bread
a loaf bread version of our carrot cake, cream cheese frosting
$3.75
Hot
coffee
serving George Howell
specialty loose teas
housemade chai
housemade cocoa
mulled apple cider
seasonal
lavender milk & honey
steamed milk with our housemade honey lavender syrup
Espresso
hot or iced
George Howell’s Alchemy
espresso, cappuccino, macchiato, latté, mocha
Cold
ALCHEMY cold brew
housemade iced teas
fresh-squeezed orange juice
ronnybrook farms chocolate milk
saratoga bottled water
bottled sodas
Pies
our pies are baked seasonally in an effort to use fresh and local ingredients as much as possible, but without overly depriving you of year-round deliciousness
fruit pies
$37.00
custard pies
$35.00
cream pies
$32.00
Re-usable Pie Pans
prices above include the $2.00 deposit on our reusable pie pans. return your pan for $2.00 off any purchase or 2 FREE cookies!
Place an Order
We require only 24 hours notice for most pie orders! Please check the current season pie list below for available pie flavors. Give us a call at (718) 766-7419 to place your order.
Winter
Fruit Pies
Apple
Bacon Apple Cheddar
Apple Rosemary Bramble with cranberries, blackberries, and blueberries
Blackberry Apple with cheddar crust
Pear Ginger Crisp vegan
Poached Pear Mincemeat with apricot and golden raisin
Sour Cherry
Bacon Apple Cheddar
Apple Rosemary Bramble with cranberries, blackberries, and blueberries
Blackberry Apple with cheddar crust
Pear Ginger Crisp vegan
Poached Pear Mincemeat with apricot and golden raisin
Sour Cherry
Custard Pies
Molasses Pecan
Maple Walnut
Red Velvet Custard
Guava Chess with Orange Spiced Creme Fraiche
Black-Bottom Lemon
Maple Walnut
Red Velvet Custard
Guava Chess with Orange Spiced Creme Fraiche
Black-Bottom Lemon
Cream Pies
Key-Lime
Bittersweet Chocolate Mousse
Carnie Pie - 3 layers - salted caramel peanuts, chocolate mousse, fresh cream
Coconut Cream
Banana Cream
Peanut Butter
Bittersweet Chocolate Mousse
Carnie Pie - 3 layers - salted caramel peanuts, chocolate mousse, fresh cream
Coconut Cream
Banana Cream
Peanut Butter
Spring
Fruit Pies
Apple
Blackberry Apple with cheddar crust
Pear Ginger Crisp vegan
Sour Cherry
Plum Crumble
Strawberry Rhubarb
Blackberry Apple with cheddar crust
Pear Ginger Crisp vegan
Sour Cherry
Plum Crumble
Strawberry Rhubarb
Custard Pies
Chocolate Bourbon Pecan
Preserved Apricot & Almond Custard
Lemon Lavender Chess with poppy seeds
Preserved Apricot & Almond Custard
Lemon Lavender Chess with poppy seeds
Cream Pies:
Key-Lime
Bittersweet Chocolate Mousse
Carnie Pie - 3 layers - salted caramel peanuts, chocolate mousse, fresh cream
Coconut Cream
Peanut Butter
Bittersweet Chocolate Mousse
Carnie Pie - 3 layers - salted caramel peanuts, chocolate mousse, fresh cream
Coconut Cream
Peanut Butter
Summer
Fruit Pies
Strawberry Rhubarb
Blackberry Rhubarb
Blueberry
Peach
Apricot Nectarine
Blackberry Apricot
Blackberry Rhubarb
Blueberry
Peach
Apricot Nectarine
Blackberry Apricot
Custard Pies
Lemon Lavender Chess with poppy seeds
Chocolate Bourbon Pecan
Chocolate Bourbon Pecan
Cream Pies
Key-Lime
Bittersweet Chocolate Mousse
Mocha Pudding - with bourbon caramel whipped cream
Peanut Butter
Bittersweet Chocolate Mousse
Mocha Pudding - with bourbon caramel whipped cream
Peanut Butter
Fall
Fruit Pies:
Apple
Apple Cardamon Crumb
Blackberry Apple with cheddar crust
Pear Ginger Crisp vegan
Pear Cranberry Dark Chocolate
Plum Crumble
Raspberry Plum with pecan crumble
Apple Cardamon Crumb
Blackberry Apple with cheddar crust
Pear Ginger Crisp vegan
Pear Cranberry Dark Chocolate
Plum Crumble
Raspberry Plum with pecan crumble
Custard Pies
Molasses Pecan
Maple Bourbon Walnut
Pumpkin
Maple Bourbon Walnut
Pumpkin
Cream Pies
Key-Lime
Bittersweet Chocolate Mousse
Peanut Butter
Bittersweet Chocolate Mousse
Peanut Butter
Cakes
Red Velvet
tangy cocoa cake with it's signature red color paired best with our cream cheese frosting
Carrot Cake
moist cake loaded with carrots, raisins, pineapple, and walnuts
Dark Chocolate
rich, moist dark chocolate cake
Vanilla
classic, all-butter, fluffy vanilla cake
Chocolate Bourbon Bundt Cake
our rich, chocolate cake drenched in bourbon buttermilk glaze
$50.00
Strawberry Shortcake
vanilla cake, fresh strawberries, and vanilla cream
Frosting Choices
Cream Cheese
tangy and creamy
Dark Chocolate
rich and smooth
Vanilla Buttercream
classic
Lemon Buttercream
zesty and bright
Botanical Buttercreams
lavender, rosehip & hibiscus, earl grey, rose petal, elderflower
Espresso Buttercream
creamy buttercream whipped with George Howell's Alchemy espresso
Mocha Buttercream
espresso buttercream meets dark cocoa
served from 9 am to 3 pm Saturday and Sunday
Granola & Yogurt
To stay or to go
our homemade granola is chock-full of fruits and nuts and sweetened only with maple syrup. local and organic yogurt with homemade fruit compote or honey ❤ have granola with steamed milk for a cozy treat!
$7.00
Biscuit Sandwiches
Baked Egg & Cheese
buttermilk biscuit, organic baked egg with cracked pepper and fresh thyme and your choice of cheese
$5.50
Add
roasted tomatoes(seasonal)
$2.00
Add
crispy, thick-cut bacon
$2.00
Add
breakfast sausage patty,
$2.00
Add
caramelized apples (seasonal)
$2.00
Bacon Apple Cheddar
buttermilk biscuit with crispy thick-cut bacon, caramelized apples, and sharp cheddar, with maple syrup and hot sauce
$7.00
Roasted Heirloom Tomato & Cheddar
summertime favorite, roasted local heirloom tomatoes with fresh thyme and sharp cheddar
$5.50
Quiche & Pot Pies
daily specials served hot with side salad
Quiche slice
$8.00
Pot pie
$10.75